Some jewelry pieces are nice to look at, but others become personal favorites. Those are the ones people come back to and reorder, either for themselves or as gifts. That’s exactly what’s happening with custom pieces from Mint & Lily. Buyers aren’t just purchasing once. They’re returning again and again for the same designs.
In this blog, we’ll look at the top 5 custom Mint & Lily designs that buyers keep reordering and why these pieces hold such strong appeal. If you’re thinking about buying custom jewelry but want something proven and safe. Mint & lily
1. Personalized Name Necklace
This is easily the most reordered custom item. The personalized name necklace continues to be a favorite because it feels special every single time.
Buyers often reorder this necklace for different people. One for themselves, one for a partner, another for a close friend. The clean font and simple chain make it easy to wear daily, which is why people don’t hesitate to buy it again.
Many customers say they reorder this necklace because it never feels outdated. Even after months of wear, it still feels meaningful. That lasting value is what turns a one-time buyer into a repeat customer.
You’ll see different styles and font options inside the Mint & Lily custom jewelry collection, which helps buyers customize each reorder slightly.
2. Birthstone Name Necklace
Combining two personal elements in one piece is a big reason this design gets reordered. The birthstone name necklace includes both a name and a stone that represents a birth month.
Customers often reorder this necklace when a new family member is born or for special milestones like birthdays and Mother’s Day. It becomes a tradition rather than just a purchase.
Reviews frequently mention that buyers love how the birthstone adds a soft touch of color without overpowering the design. That balance makes it wearable and emotional at the same time.
According to personalized jewelry trends, pieces that mix personalization with symbolism are the most likely to be reordered.
3. Initial Pendant Necklace
The initial pendant necklace is a quieter form of customization, and that’s exactly why buyers keep coming back for it. Instead of a full name, this design features a single letter that still feels meaningful.
Customers often reorder this piece to represent different people in their lives. Some buy multiple initials to layer together, while others purchase the same design as gifts for friends.
The simple shape makes this necklace easy to wear with almost anything. Buyers say it’s one of those pieces that never feels like “too much,” which keeps it in regular rotation.
You can find several versions of this necklace in the Mint & Lily custom jewelry collection, making it easy to reorder without repeating the exact same look.
4. Engraved Bar Necklace
The engraved bar necklace is another custom design that buyers frequently reorder. This piece allows short names, initials, or meaningful dates to be engraved on a sleek bar.
Customers often reorder this necklace for anniversaries, graduations, or life milestones. Many reviews mention buying the same necklace multiple times for different occasions.
What makes this piece special is its clean and modern look. Even with engraving, it stays minimal and stylish. Buyers like that it doesn’t scream “custom,” but still feels deeply personal.
This type of understated personalization is a key reason it shows up often in personalized jewelry trends reports.
5. Custom Charm Necklace
Last on the list is the custom charm necklace, a design buyers love because it grows with time. Instead of a single fixed message, this necklace allows customers to add charms that represent different moments.
Buyers often reorder charms rather than the full necklace. A new charm might represent a child, a memory, or a personal achievement. Over time, the necklace becomes a story.
Customers say this is one of the most emotional pieces they own, which explains why they keep returning. Each reorder adds meaning rather than replacing the original item.
You can see charm options inside the Mint & Lily custom jewelry collection, which helps buyers plan future additions.
Why Buyers Keep Reordering These Designs
Across customer reviews, a few clear reasons stand out:
- Custom pieces feel personal, not generic
- Designs stay stylish over time
- Jewelry fits everyday wear
- Gifts feel thoughtful without being risky
- Reordering feels meaningful, not repetitive
When a product delivers both emotional value and daily usability, customers don’t hesitate to buy again.
Final Thoughts
Custom jewelry only works when it feels personal and wearable at the same time. These top 5 custom Mint & Lily designs do exactly that, which is why buyers keep reordering them for themselves and the people they love.